Skip to main content

Table 2 Estimation of the overall performance of the use of ECG as biometric

From: Individual identification via electrocardiogram analysis

References

IR (%)

AEER

IRW

AW

WIR (%)

WA (%)

Agrafioti and Hatzinakos [85]

100.00

na

0.010

na

0.61

na

Agrafioti and Hatzinakos [83]

96.20

0.87

0.020

0.10

2.35

0.08

Biel et al. [1]

98.00

na

0.010

na

0.86

na

Boumbarov et al. [120]

86.11

na

0.000

na

0.34

na

Chan et al. [48]

89.00

na

0.020

na

1.94

na

Chan et al. [49]

100.00

na

0.030

na

2.62

na

Chen et al. [90]

91.20

na

0.010

na

0.76

na

Fang and Chan [28]

95.00

na

0.040

na

4.15

na

Fatemian and Hatzinakos [64]

99.63

na

0.010

na

1.17

na

Israel et al. [14]

100.00

na

0.010

na

1.27

na

Khalil and Sufi [35]

na

na

na

na

na

na

Kim et al. [45]

Na

na

na

na

na

na

Kyoso and Uchiyama [4]

94.20

na

0.000

na

0.37

na

Loong et al. [93]

100.00

na

0.010

na

0.66

na

Lourenco et al. [65]

94.30

10.10

0.010

0.03

0.66

0.28

Odinaka et al. [54]

99.00

0.37

0.012

0.46

11.63

0.17

Pathoumvanh et al. [132]

97.00

na

0.000

na

0.42

na

Pereira et al. [112]

99.00

0.70

0.030

0.13

3.33

0.09

Safie et al. [70]

93.60

na

0.050

na

4.58

na

Shen and Tompkins [26]

95.30

na

0.070

na

6.99

na

Silva et al. [113]

na

na

na

na

na

 

Singh [77]

82.00

0.10

0.030

0.13

2.61

0.01

Singh and Gupta [76]

99.00

na

0.020

na

2.16

na

Sriram et al. [114]

97.00

15.00

0.010

0.03

0.72

0.44

Tawfik and Kamal [78]

99.08

na

0.010

na

0.95

na

Wan and Yao [59]

100.00

na

0.020

na

1.66

na

Wang et al. [87]

100.00

na

0.010

na

1.14

na

Wubbeler et al. [31]

99.00

0.03

0.030

0.13

3.20

0.00

Yao and Wan [47]

91.48

na

0.010

na

0.80

na

Zhang and Wei [27]

97.40

na

0.220

na

21.35

na

Zhao et al. [94]

95.00

na

0.180

na

16.93

na

Total

    

96.22

1.16

  1. IR identification rate, AEER equal error rate for authentication scenarios, IRW IR weights, AW AEER weights, WIR weighted IR, WA weighted AEEE, na indicates that information is not not available or not computable.